Some pundits are now saying that
there is some hope for compromise on the budget, tax reform and reduced
spending before the end of this year. The Tax Armageddon of the combined expirations
of the Bush and payroll tax cuts on December 31, 2012 might prompt our
government to some last minute action. This “solution” will be less than “strategic”
to say the least – just crisis management like the debt ceiling debacle of last
summer.
I submit that a major contributor
to this chaos is the Americans for Tax
Reform (“ATR”) and it’s President, Grover Norquist. Norquist
and ATR are the developers of the “No-Tax Pledge,” or in their parlance, the
taxpayer protection pledge. The organization’s description starts as follows: “Americans
for Tax Reform opposes all tax increases as a matter of principle.”
Of course, Norquist takes this
to the absurd. To cite just two examples: ATR opposes closing any loopholes for
any reason, or for even ending ineffective and market distorting Ethanol
subsidies, arguing these would both be tax increases. I will not get into the
flawed logic of ATR’s “starve the beast” philosophy here; however, suffice it
to say that our recent history has shown that tax cuts are generally
accompanied by increases in government spending, not decreases.
41 Senators, 236 House Members
and 1,263 state legislators have signed the “Pledge,” scared to death of
Norquist’s wrath and threats of electoral retaliation.
America needs an anti-Norquist with
matching political cunning. The pledge we should ask candidates to sign is a
“No Pledge” Pledge. Other than
the Pledge of Allegiance, all others should be out. We need people of honor and
integrity in government, individuals who we trust to have wisdom to balance
principle with compromise. Many veteran legislators in Washington possess these
sensibilities, but are punished for showing them by the ATR.
Norquist’s influence needs to be
neutered and exposed for what it is – horribly crippling demagoguery over public
policy and the implementation of true tax reform. Maybe I will be scolded by
some for making analogy to the terrible images of McCarthyism; but similar fears
are engendered in the hearts of politicians today. It’s time to stand up
against ATR and to just say no to the “No-Tax Pledge”.
I believe money would pour into
an organization supporting and backing the idea of a “NO PLEGDE” PLEDGE. I am
not promulgating the idea big government or limited government, higher taxes or
lower taxes; rather for supporting a democracy that actually works as intended.
To whom should we write our
checks?